Is Creatine Worth It For Muscle Growth?

Creatine is a common, worldwide supplement used by millions of people – including me. 

In 2022, a study in the journal of Strength and Conditioning found creatine to be the most popular supplement in male bodybuilders.

But some people are still wondering is creatine worth it? 

It’s a good question to ask. Just because millions of people use it, doesn’t necessarily mean that. That said, in the vast majority of cases creatine is worth taking.

Let me explain why, as well as what goals creatine is worth taking for.  

Why is creatine worth it?

If you lift weights and are interested in strength training, yes creatine is worth taking.

I take creatine monohydrate every day to keep my muscle stores topped up. I’ve been taking it for over 10 years now and believe that I’ve benefited from it.

Although there are now many types of creatine, monohydrate is the most basic form. Entry level if you like. But it’s also the only variation you’re more than likely need.

If you’re looking for reassurance, you can’t get a more studied supplement than creatine. There are over 700 human studies on its supplementation. In 2023, a new meta-analysis study on creatine was released – the first in 20 years.

The bottom line of the new study was this: creatine will help increase your rate of muscle growth by 33%. In my view, that makes creatine well worth taking.

But creatine also brings many more benefits to your training and overall health. Let’s take a look at why creatine is worth supplementing with.

ben deadlift starting position

First up, it’s effective. Most people will see a lifting benefit from taking creatine. This could be strength gains, power output, more energy on the gym floor and even neurological benefits. Creatine attracts water into your muscles, so you may look a little fuller too. 

The other great thing is that creatine monohydrate supplement isn’t over-priced. The same can’t be said for the likes of a highly marketed pre-workout or even a creatine variety. You might see creatine in different guises including creatine pyruvate, micronized, malate, AKG, gluconate, magnesium chelate. The list goes on. 

Keep things simple, cheap and backed up by science and stick with creatine monohydrate. It’s all you need. 

My view is that creatine is well worth it. Have a look at my personal review on the best creatine here.

Let’s find out what for exactly, plus tackle a few of the negative associations that often come up.

Is creatine worth it for muscle growth?

crazy nutrition crn-5 banner 4

Creatine won’t help you to directly build muscle fibres in the same way that protein will. Creatine isn’t about this. 

Creatine helps facilitate an energy pathway in your muscles. In science terms, the creatine energy system helps to convert ADP to ATP (the body’s energy currency). It does this by releasing a high-energy phosphate molecule to go from adenosine di-phosphate (ADP) to adenosine tri-phosphate (ATP). So, you can say that creatine is an energy recycler.

What’s this got to do with muscle growth?

Well, muscles use ATP for energy. If ATP can be recreated in your muscles rapidly thanks to creatine, your lifting is going to be efficient. This means that creatine comes in handy to help you bust out an extra rep or two when your energy stores are flailing. 

Creatine’s main role is to quickly reproduce energy during the first few seconds (up to 30 seconds) of activity. Because of its quick nature, creatine helps with explosive exercises, such as weight lifting and strength training. 

By increasing energy efficiency within your muscles, you’ll be able to increase your training volume. You might be able to add an extra 5 kgs or 10lbs on to the bar. As you know, more weight lifted over time is going to result in muscle growth. 

Supplementing with creatine has been scientifically shown to increase muscle mass. So yes, in an indirect way creatine is worth it for muscle growth thanks to the energy systems that it charges up. 

ben shoulder lat raise start

Is creatine worth it for beginners?

You’ll read many articles saying that creatine is worth it for beginners. Creatine is perfectly safe for beginners to take, but let me tell you why they’re wrong.

If you’re stepping into the gym for the very first time to lift weights, I wouldn’t worry about taking creatine. 

In fact, if you’re a complete beginner when it comes to strength training, I’d say creatine isn’t worth taking for the first 6 months at least. Possibly even a year. 

The reason is that you’ll make big natural gains during those first few months. You don’t really need an extra boost straight away. 

Furthermore, it’s important to know what you can do in the gym without anything else. You need to learn the lifting moves, become acquainted with free weights and some of the machines. You need to learn about your and how it reacts to weight lifting. This will all give you a great baseline from which you can work with. 

With a regular training programme, a beginner’s body will be adapting quickly, growing muscle and getting stronger. Even if creatine does bring its benefits, it’s likely they won’t even be noticeable anyway during the glorious newbie phase. 

All that being said, it won’t do a beginner lifter any harm to take creatine. But my advice would be to get to know your body when strength training and lifting weights first. Then when you’ve got a good base and start to take supplements, you’ll understand and feel the impact they have on your body. 

Is taking creatine healthy for you?

creatine monohydrate supplement with bag and shaker

Creatine is not really known as a health supplement. It won’t make you healthier and benefit your body in the same way that vitamins and minerals do.

Let me explain. 

As mentioned above, creatine is all about efficient use of energy supplies. Its job is to recycle energy for your muscles to use again. This all happens in the first 10 seconds or so of explosive exercise. 

Often unknown health benefits of creatine are that it can aid brain health, boost neuroprotective effects and improve cognition. 

A scientific review of all the literature concluded that creatine has the potential to improve brain functioning and has scope to help with degenerative brain diseases, such as Alzheimer’s. 

Although this hasn’t been proven conclusively, it’s all very interesting and shows the multiple benefits that creatine can have. It’s worth saying that everyone might not see the benefits of creatine, but importantly, there are no negative impacts associated with taking creatine. 

With this in mind, I’d say that creatine is worth taking for the potential health benefits to the brain alone, nevermind the weight lifting benefits! 

crazy nutrition crn-5 banner

What are the negative effects of creatine?

Generally speaking, there are very few negative effects of creatine to make it not worth taking. 

Negative issues put forward in the past include stomach issues and diarrhoea. This can be an issue with almost anything. 

Creatine will also draw water into your muscles. This isn’t a bad thing, but some people don’t like the extra water retention and weight gain with creatine. Some people have associated the water movement with being more thirsty. I think it’s good advice to drink more water with creatine.

The water retention of creatine may be a benefit as it will make you look bigger. Intracellular water may even lead to muscle growth through cellular swelling.

Some people have associated creatine with hair loss as it increases the formation of DHT. No study has reported hair loss or baldness from creatine.

The other argument often put forward is potential kidney damage with creatine. A by-product of the energy recycling in your muscles is creatinine. This is a waste product. Your body excretes creatinine via your kidneys.

Long term studies on people with healthy kidneys have shown creatine to be safe. No adverse effects have been shown.  

If you suffer from kidney issues and you’re considering taking creatine, consult your doctor first. 

There are very few negative impacts associated with creatine. You can even take gone out of date creatine and most likely be fine!

Who shouldn’t take creatine?

creatine bag and bottle shaker

With negative impacts very rare from creatine, most people should be absolutely fine with supplementation. 

If you have an existing medical condition, you should always ask your doctor before taking anything new that could affect your condition or the medication you’re taking. 

This is particularly true for those with existing kidney and liver issues. 

With creatine being a dietary supplement, it hasn’t been tested on children and teenagers. In all likelihood, creatine would be fine, if not beneficial. But because it hasn’t been tested fully, it’s not possible to conclusively draw these conclusions. 

Creatine has been tested on pregnant women. In fact, this study review concluded that creatine is safe for pregnant mothers and is likely to benefit the baby both pre- and post-partum. 

What creatine doesn’t do

Creatine is an often misunderstood supplement. Hell, I was taking it for years without fully realising what it actually did. Not advised, but we all do this in one way or another when we’re growing up. 

Creatine doesn’t do the following:

  • It doesn’t make you instantly stronger
  • It’s not a pre-workout supplement
  • It’s not a steroid
  • It’s not anabolic
  • It’s not illegal

Is creatine worth the risk?

Creatine is a safe supplement. Hundreds of scientific studies have shown this. 

It’s also a natural product found in meat, dairy and some fish. Estimates vary, but you’ll get around anywhere between 1-5g of creatine for every 0.5-2lb (225-900g) of beef. 

Creatine is made up of three peptide molecules (arginine, glycine and methionine). It contains no stimulants and is perfectly fine to take before bed and any time of day,

Essentially, creatine is a safe and effective supplement. Studies, like this one, have demonstrated the multiple benefits of taking creatine for those taking part in resistance training. 70% reported improvements, with 30% showing no impact. No negatives. 

For lifting performance and strength, the worst that can happen is that nothing happens. The best is that you’ll get stronger and your lifts will go up.

With very, very little risk, creatine is certainly worth it. 

Is creatine worth the cost?

creatine in front of plant

Relatively speaking, creatine monohydrate is not expensive. Compared to other training supplements, it’s pretty cheap!

I would stay away from the other creatine variants. I’m talking creatine ethyl ester and HCL. I’m not saying these variants don’t work, but they’re nowhere near as well studied as creatine monohydrate, potentially not as effective and probably double the cost (if not more).

At one of my go to supplement proteins, Myprotein.com, you can pick up a 0.5lb bag (250g) for less than $30 (£20). So, even with a small 0.5lb bag, you’re getting 50 servings of creatine. You’d have to eat way over 100 big steaks to get anywhere near this amount. I think that’ll cost more than $30…

You always get better value for money when you buy in bulk of course. It’s worth doing this if you can.

So, stick with creatine monohydrate and it will be well worth the cost. 

Wrap up on is creatine worth it

Top Pick
Crazy Nutrition Ultimate CRN-5
4.5

Crazy Nutrition have created an ultimate creatine all in one formula. High quality ingredients and an excellent product.

Pros:
  • Multiple creatine types in one
  • Added electrolytes for hydration
  • 5g serving of creatine
  • Multiple flavors
  • Tub
Cons:
  • No unflavored version
BUY NOW
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

So, is creatine really worth it? There’s no doubt that it is for almost everyone who cares about their health and likes to lift weights.

With safety concerns being a non-starter for most, it’s a no-brainer to give creatine a go. The best that can happen is that you benefit with increased power and strength. The worst that can happen is that you don’t see any impact. 

It’s worth saying though that creatine is not a miracle worker. It’s not a magic pill (or powder) for all your lifting needs. 

Creatine is a supplement. Like all supplements, it should be taken in conjunction with a good, protein filled diet, a solid and consistent training programme, as well as plenty of rest. You can take a look at my daily supplement stack here.


Related Articles On Creatine:

ben hardman strength bible deadlift standards

Ben is passionate about getting strong both physically and mentally. He’s been obsessed with all things health and muscle building for over 17 years. In between strength and conditioning training five times a week, Ben is a professional fitness writer. Ben has a first class Biology degree, is a fully qualified teacher and is completing his L3 Personal Trainer qualification.

Leave a comment

white envelope graphic png

Join The MORE STRENGTH Newsletter

Designed to help you build all-round, long-lasting strength. Topics of training, nutrition, mindset, health and recovery.