Is Creatine HCL Worth Taking? (Better Than Monohydrate?)

I’ve been taking creatine monohydrate for over 15 years now. It’s one of my staple supplements that I always try to have in my cupboard. 

But one of the main gripes that people have with creatine monohydrate is that it causes water retention and bloating. 

As well as monohydrate, there is a whole range of other types of creatine. One of them is creatine HCL, or creatine hydrochloride to give it’s full name.

Curious to find out more, I’ve been looking into creatine HCL and reading up on the studies comparing HCL to creatine monohydrate. I also decided to buy a bag of creatine hydrochloride powder from Bulk to see if it’s worth taking myself. 

Benefits of Creatine HCL

The science points out that creatine hydrochloride is much more water soluble than monohydrate.

This has a two-fold impact:

  • Quicker absorption rates into the body
  • Less water retention in cells

For some people and for those who suffer with stomach sensitivities, this could be a big bonus. 

Personally speaking, I’ve never had any issues with a good quality creatine monohydrate. I tend to go for a micronized creatine. One of my recent favourites is Warrior. You can read my Warrior creatine review here.

I’ve not particularly noticed excessive water retention or had any stomach issues. But in the name of science, I wanted to try creatine HCL for myself. 

First up, it’s fairly affordable with prices ranging from $0.15 (£0.12p) to $0.6 (£0.45p) per serving.

bulk creatine hcl

Downsides to HCL

The major issue for me was the taste.

I went for unflavoured, just as I do with monohydrate. Before giving it a try, I made the mistake of adding it to my post-workout protein shake and woah I wasn’t expecting that!

The Bulk creatine HCL was so sharp and with an added salt taste – it was almost undrinkable. At first I thought my protein had gone off or something, then I realised it was the HCL. 

So, if you are going to buy creatine HCL don’t go for unflavoured powder. I’ve still got a few hundred grams that I need to get through!

I’d recommend going for a flavoured version, such as the Kaged lemon lime creatine HCL or even the HCL vegetable caps.  

kaged creatine hcl product

What is creatine HCL?

Creatine HCL is a form of the highly popular sports nutrition supplement creatine. The HCL stands for hydrochloride. 

In basic terms, it’s a molecule of creatine bonded to a hydrochloride salt with the main aim of increasing absorption from the intestine into the bloodstream and bioavailability from the blood to your muscles.

Because it’s more soluble, the theory is that you don’t have to consume as much water with it, which can lead to less bloating. The other benefit is that the reduced time in your gastrointestinal system results in fewer complaints.

Related read: Does Creatine Make You Gain Weight?

Creatine HCL vs Creatine Monohydrate

warrior micronized creatine monohydrate tub

Creatine HCL and creatine monohydrate are both forms of creatine. The aim of creatine supplementation is to increase muscular creatine levels, which helps produce more ATP during times of intense exercise. Both forms of creatine do that. 

The main difference lies in their chemical structure. Creatine HCL is formed by attaching a hydrochloride group to the creatine molecule, while creatine monohydrate is created by bonding creatine to a water molecule.

The HCL group lowers the pH, which makes creatine HCL more stable and increases its solubility. A study on the chemical structures found creatine hydrochloride to be 38 times more soluble than creatine monohydrate. In theory, this means you can have a smaller dose and achieve the same results.

HCL vs monohydrate strength differences?

One of the main reasons people take creatine is to improve strength performance at the gym or explosiveness and power when taking part in sports.

So, is there any difference in strength performance between HCL and monohydrate?

To summarise, the jury is still very much out. There have only been a handful of studies into this and the results of a difference aren’t conclusive.

For example, a study on 40 recreational weightlifters comparing creatine HCL to monohydrate found that all subject groups made strength gains and performance was improved across the body. 

A study comparing HCL vs monohydrate on 11 Brazilian Olympic gymnasts found that all experienced lean mass gains and that strength improvements were noticed for both supplements after 30 days.

Another study on recreational lifers, looking at short term effects of performance and hormonal changes, found there to be no differences between HCL and mono.  

That said, both forms make a difference, backing up the claims that creatine is worth it for muscle growth.

HCL vs monohydrate body composition differences?

Interestingly, the study on 40 recreational weightlifters found that HCL had more positive impacts on fat mass and fat free mass. Fat mass showed a significant difference, whereas fat free mass (i.e. lean body mass), only increased in one group. 

The Brazilian Olympic gymnast study also found HCL to have a significant impact on body fat percentage. 

This indicates that creatine HCL may be able to better influence body composition changes compared to monohydrate.

Summary: Creatine HCL vs Monohydrate

No significant differences in strength performance and muscular gains between HCL and monohydrate. Both will support your training well.
Mild evidence to suggest HCL may have additional benefits for fat loss
Creatine HCL will reduce extra water storage

Potential Side Effects of creatine HCL?

Generally, creatine HCL is considered to be incredibly safe, but, like any supplement, it may come with a few potential side effects. The main issues you might experience are digestive discomforts.

If you’ve taken creatine monohydrate with no problems before, you should be absolutely fine with HCL. 

Why does Creatine HCL taste so bad?

Here’s what I wanted to know – why does creatine HCL taste so bad?!

Creatine HCL has a notoriously sharp, sour, tangy and unappealing taste. I wasn’t expecting it to be so bad seeing as monohydrate has zero taste, but it was. 

Of course, the reason behind this taste is the presence of a hydrochloride salt. By design, adding the hydrochloride group to the creatine molecule lowers the pH of the compound, making it more acidic. Furthermore, most creatine HCL supplements are unflavoured, meaning they don’t contain any sweeteners or flavourings to mask the bitter taste. 

There’s probably a good reason for this, in that the manufacturer would have to add a tonne of sugar and sweetness to try and overpower the sourness in the unflavoured version. Not worth it.

Final verdict on creatine HCL

The limited science tells us there are no significant differences in strength performance and muscle gains between creatine HCL and monohydrate. 

As I’ve encountered no stomach issues and water weight gain with monohydrate, there’s no real reason for me to fully switch over, especially considering the bad taste. 

That said, I would be interested to taste the flavoured versions of HCL to see if these are any better. The Kaged creatine HCL comes with over 650 5* reviews and a 96% recommendation rate, which tells me there’s something good in there. By contrast the Bulk version I tried has an average rating of 3.5/5.

While we’re on the subject, you can take a look at my best creatine supplements here.

Read more on creatine

ben hardman strength bible deadlift standards

Ben is passionate about getting strong both physically and mentally. He’s been obsessed with all things health and muscle building for over 17 years. In between strength and conditioning training five times a week, Ben is a professional fitness writer. Ben has a first class Biology degree, is a fully qualified teacher and is completing his L3 Personal Trainer qualification.

white envelope graphic png

Join The MORE STRENGTH Newsletter

Designed to help you build all-round, long-lasting strength. Topics of training, nutrition, mindset, health and recovery.