Creatine While Cutting (A Good Idea Or One To Avoid?)

Key Takeaways

> Yes, it’s a good idea to take creatine when cutting.

> Creatine helps build and preserve muscle, which is calorically expensive. This increased muscle can help you burn more calories over time.

> Plenty of other benefits to taking creatine daily, including for your brain, mitochondria and general wellness.

> The potential downsides of creatine, such as increased water retention, won’t make much difference to your appearance while cutting and are far outweighed by the benefits
.

You probably already know that creatine is an exceptional supplement for strength training, muscle building and intense exercises. But what about the cutting phase of the training cycle? Should you take creatine while cutting? 

The main reason that people question creatine during the cutting phase is because of its association with water retention and potentially making you look a little ‘soft’.

On balance, I don’t believe that creatine causes detrimental effects during cutting. In fact, creatine brings multiple benefits to your cut that are science-backed. The bottom line is:

Using creatine while cutting can help you to maintain hard-earned muscle, which increases your basal metabolic rate. This can help you burn more calories and body fat over time. I’d certainly keep creatine supplementation as part of your daily health routine to support you in achieving your desired physique.

We’ll go through the pros and cons of creatine when cutting to give you the full picture, so you can make your own mind up.

Benefits of taking creatine while cutting

Cutting involves following a reduced calorie diet to burn fat and drop weight. The aim is to decrease body fat percentage and reveal more definition to your physique.

With a reduced calorie intake, there can be concerns with potential muscle loss during the process. This is where creatine can help.

Here are some of the creatine benefits while cutting:

Preserves muscle mass

The overall effect of creatine is to help build muscle mass, as demonstrated in this recent meta-analysis study.

Thanks to the role creatine plays in recycling ADP into ATP over short bursts of exercise, muscles use energy more efficiently when supplementing with creatine. This can help reduce the loss of muscle tissue during a calorie deficit. 

It’s why I argue strongly in favour here as to why creatine is worth it for muscle growth.

Improves strength

Many lifters experience a decrease in strength when dieting due to low glycogen levels and a natural drop in energy. Supplementing with creatine can help counteract this effect by maintaining strength and power.

Many lifters and bodybuilders insist on taking creatine while cutting. And I agree.

Increases resting metabolic rate

Your resting or basal metabolic rate (BMR) is the amount of energy your body burns at rest.

As muscle is calorically expensive, it takes more energy to maintain it. This means that more muscle helps to burn more calories on a daily basis.

Supports general health

Research shows that creatine can boost brain function, cognition and general well-being.

This is important during a cutting cycle as mood and well-being can be impacted by a decreased calorie intake.

There are tonnes of benefits to creatine.

Is there any truth to the potential drawbacks of creatine when cutting?

The major argument against using creatine while cutting is the water retention it causes. 

Studies, such as this one in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, have shown that taking creatine over a prolonged period can significantly increase water weight content.

For lifters trying to lose body fat in order to appear cut and toned, this notion of increased water retention can be off-putting. It’s true, creatine can make you gain weight.

But I don’t see it as a major problem. Taking creatine isn’t going to cause a retention in fat. Quite the opposite.

For this reason, a little bit of extra water isn’t going to significantly impact physical appearance in my opinion. When considered against the positives of creatine when cutting, I think it’s insignificant. 

Feeling thirsty

On the water retention, you may feel thirstier when taking creatine.

It’s important to stay fully hydrated, which may involve drinking a little more water during the day than what you’re used to. This is nothing major, maybe an extra glass or two – 3 to 4 litres of water a day is recommended for most. 

Stomach issues?

Another possible downside of taking creatine when cutting is the possible associations with bloating and gastrointestinal issues. Stomach upsets, cramps and bloating have been reported anecdotally by some people. I think this comes more down to the individual rather than the supplement itself. 

Bloating and stomach upset can occur with a variety of foods and supplements. I think it’s a case of trying it out and seeing how sensitive you are. It’s worth saying that the vast majority of creatine users experience no side effects at all. I’m one of those people and I’ve been taking creatine for over 15 years now. 

To minimise any potential side-effects, it’s recommended to start with a lower dose and gradually increase it over time. This will allow the body to adapt more smoothly.

How to use creatine while cutting?

Ok, by now hopefully you’ve got the impression that you should take creatine while cutting.

So, how much should you take? Does this need to change compared to how much creatine you take during a bulk?

In short, no. The best plan of action is to take 5-10g of creatine every day, come rain or shine, bulk or cut. 

While it’s true that our bodies can synthesise creatine, it doesn’t do so in great doses. This is why supplementation is important. Even taking creatine on rest days.

I take 5g in the morning and 5g of creatine post-workout. If you’re brand new to this supplement, it takes anywhere from seven days to a month for creatine to take full effect. Read more on how long creatine takes to work here.

In terms of timing around workouts, the science shows a slight favouring to post-workout supplementation. But there’s not much in it. Also, don’t worry too much about the whole loading and maintenance phases. Unnecessary. Just stick to regular daily doses. 

There are now lots of different types of creatine, all fighting to be the most absorbable. I think this is a combination of splitting hairs and marketing to buy a ‘better’ version. My advice is to stick to a micronised creatine monohydrate. Keep it simple. 

You can check out my favourite and best creatine sources here.

best creatine supplements

Other important supplements during the ‘cutting’ phase

As you know, the cutting phase refers to a time where you eat fewer calories than you burn in order to reduce body fat. At the same time as losing fat, you want to preserve as much lean muscle mass as possible. 

A good way to do this is to train hard, eat the correct food sources (albeit a reduced amount) and help your body with supplements where necessary.

These supplements won’t necessarily get you shredded as in burn extra calories, but they are some of the best supplements you can take on a cut for general health and to help you achieve your fitness goals. These include:

  • Whey protein – No surprises here, you need excellent protein intake to maintain as much muscle as possible. Whey protein is also naturally low in calories and carbs.
  • Multivitamin – Important to keep up good stocks of vitamins and minerals at a time when your body could be lacking
  • Zinc and magnesium – Good for general health, recovery and help you get a good sleep
  • Pre-workout – Will give you a boost of energy and focus to help you make the most of your workouts

During the cutting phase, many individuals turn to supplements like creatine to help support and protect muscles.

It’s for this reason why, yes you should take creatine while cutting.

Liked that? Read more about creatine…

ben hardman strength bible deadlift standards

Ben is passionate about getting strong both physically and mentally. He’s been obsessed with all things health and muscle building for over 17 years. In between strength and conditioning training five times a week, Ben is a professional fitness writer. Ben has a first class Biology degree, is a fully qualified teacher and is completing his L3 Personal Trainer qualification.

white envelope graphic png

Join The MORE STRENGTH Newsletter

Designed to help you build all-round, long-lasting strength. Topics of training, nutrition, mindset, health and recovery.