Should You Deadlift and Squat On The Same Day?

Key Takeaways

> Although different movement patterns, EMG data tells us that deadlifts and squats recruit very similar muscle fibres

> As squats and deadlifts are your two biggest exercises in terms of load, performing both on the same day may negatively impact recovery and the rest your training

> Training deadlifts and squats on different days increase training frequency of the muscles. This will benefit muscle growth and strength.

One of the longest running debates in strength training circles is whether you can deadlift and squat on the same day.

The argument exists because deadlifts use both the legs and back during the lift, so you can make a solid case that they’re a leg exercise. As with all things fitness though, the truth is often a little more nuanced.

In this article I’ll outline my solid conviction as to why squatting and deadlifting shouldn’t be done on the same day.

I’ll show you scientific data to back up my case and demonstrate why you shouldn’t be putting them on the same day if you want to maximise the effect of both. We’ll take a tour of the research and, hopefully, leave you with a better understanding of strength training programming.

And before you read on, why should you care what I think?

Well, I’m a strength and conditioning coach with over 20 years’ experience. I also own a strength and conditioning gym in Stockport, UK called MyGym. There’s little I haven’t seen or worked on in my time in fitness. Let’s get to the deadlift and squats debate.

Contents

Deadlifting and Squatting On The Same Day – The Analysis Outline

To give you the short answer, I don’t think that deadlifting and squatting should done on the same day.

But to ensure that my argument is based in fact and not just some stubbornly held belief, I need to establish criteria for the comparison of a squat and deadlift.

I can’t use ‘opinion’ as a metric because it’s too subjective. My opinion could be very different to others. We could view things in different ways based on lived experiences. That’s not to say either is wrong, but there’s simply too many unknowns when it comes to an opinion-based argument.

Instead, I’m going to use lab reported electromyography (EMG) data because that’s an accurate measure of muscle stimulation during exercise. I’ll also use data about the impact that volume and intensity in the different exercises has on recovery, and subsequent exercise performance.

By looking at the data, we can understand the amount of recruitment of the different muscles in each exercise. That way, we can understand the work done by them, which will help us to appreciate the programming decisions we need to make to ensure our advice as a website is evidence-based.

chris squat mygym

Focussing on conventional deadlift and barbell back squat

To make the analysis clearer, I’ll only look at the conventional deadlift and the barbell back squat.

As umbrella terms, ‘squat’ and ‘deadlift’ are just too vague – you can garner vastly different EMG data from the different variations of the exercises to suit a particular argument. A stiff legged deadlift would produce completely different EMG data to a low-handle trap bar deadlift for example.

So, by focussing on only the two most widely used variations of an exercise, we strip out all the nuance when it comes to Romanian deadlift, trap bar deadlift, split squats, front squats etc.

Understanding Human Movement Mechanics

There are seven human movements. All exercises we perform contain one or more of these patterns. Here they are, with examples of each:

  • Squat – Any form of squat
  • Hinge – deadlift, kettlebell swing
  • Lunge – lunge, step up, split squats
  • Push – bench press, military press
  • Pull – pull up, rows
  • Rotation – Russian twists, med ball throws
  • Gait – running, walking

What we can understand from this list is that a squat and a deadlift are fundamentally different movement patterns. In biomechanical terms, a deadlift is a hinge movement, not a squat.

The reason this is relevant here is because even when the same muscles are recruited during an exercise, the firing patterns may be different. The level of muscle recruitment for each will vary.

We understand how muscles fire by looking at electromyography (EMG) data.

niall deadlift mygym

Deadlift EMG data

In a 2020 study, Martin-Fuentes et al assessed the EMG data during the deadlift. They found that the conventional deadlift primarily trained the following muscles:

  • Quads
  • Glutes
  • Spinal erectors
  • Lats
  • Hamstring

As you could expect, their study concluded that in the conventional deadlift, the major muscles recruited were the anterior thigh muscles (quads), the hamstrings, lower and mid back muscles.

Of course, there are others, but these are the main ones.

Squat EMG data

A similar study on squats was published in 2020. In the study, researchers Erdag and Yavuz found that these are the muscles recruited by squats:

  • Quads
  • Glutes
  • Hamstring
  • Spinal erectors
  • Core

The crossover is blatantly obvious here. Except for the different trunk activation (deadlifts hit the lats more, but the squats hit the core more), the muscles used by the squat and deadlift are very similar.

Importance of the muscle firing patterns

So now that we know the EMG data for the exercises, how can we draw conclusions about how to program them both?

To answer that question properly, we must look at the impact that frequency of training has on muscle size and strength…

Research by Brad Schoenfeld et al titled ‘Resistance Training Volume Enhances Muscle Hypertrophy but Not Strength in Trained Men’ drew some interesting conclusions, especially when it comes to volume and hypertrophy. Schoenfeld said:

“…muscle hypertrophy follows a dose–response relationship, with increasingly greater gains achieved with higher training volumes.“

This essentially tells us that the more frequently that you train muscles, the greater the muscle growth.

So, with that in mind, it would make more sense to split squats and deadlifts up, training them on separate days. That way you automatically double the number of days you’re training the muscles.

Rather than have a day where you do both, instead you can give them their own days.

ben deadlift top position

The biggest lift most people have is their deadlift. You can read here about the benefits of heavy deadlifts.

The deadlift is a huge movement, it recruits a lot of muscle and is a perfect way to hit the posterior chain with both heavy weight and high volume. This is the perfect muscle and strength gain combo. It’s also a good reason why you should make sure all muscles are joints are primed. Take a read of our best deadlift warm ups here.

Squats are usually the biggest leg-specific exercise most lifters will have in their arsenal. By performing them on a different day to deadlifts, you’ll be hitting these big moves when you’re at your freshest. This means you’ll manage heavier weights and higher volume – perfect for growing your legs!

So rather than have the two compete in the same workout for ever-dwindling energy and strength reserves, why not give them both their own day? That way you’ll manage to perform the best version of themselves on each workout.

Better recovery with a split deadlift and squat approach

This is another interesting point to consider. The higher volume that you train a muscle with, the more time you’ll need to allow for recovery.

This has been evidenced in research by Bartolomei et al from 2017. In their study on the recovery response from high-intensity and high-volume resistance exercise, they assessed the impact of high volume (lots of sets) and high intensity (fewer sets, but closer to failure) exercise has on muscle recovery time. Their conclusions were clear…

“Results indicate that high-volume resistance exercise results in greater performance deficits, and a greater extent of muscle damage, than a bout of high-intensity resistance exercise.“

So again, if you were to train deadlifts and squats on the same day, you’ll accumulate more volume. This would have a greater impact on the rest of your training week than if you split the exercises up.

A single workout with multiple sets of squats and deadlifts would leave your muscles more fatigued and less capable of performing at their best for longer in the week. By splitting them up, you could use a lower volume for each, allowing more time for a full and thorough recovery of the muscle and connective tissues.

This wouldn’t just improve performance by the way, it would also reduce injury risk.

You might argue that it wouldn’t particularly impact your overall training if that was your only lower body day of the week. My response would be to look at the EMG data again – you’re not just training your lower body with squats and deadlifts, you’re also hitting your spinal erectors, core and lats across the two exercises.

Final thoughts on how can I be sure that deadlifting and squatting on the same day is a bad idea?

Across the article I’ve considered far more than just opinion on the topic. Whilst strength training is a world where opinions and experience matter, you must consider hard scientific fact as well.

The case has been built across three main points…

  1. The muscles used by both exercises
  2. How training frequency impacts the response from the muscles
  3. How long the body takes to recover from exercise

When taking all of these into consideration, the logical conclusion is that if you want to make the most of both exercises, and you want to give yourself the best possible chance of recovery between workouts, split them up.

You’ll add more frequency, improve the performance on the days and balance the volume better, easing the recovery burden.

Deadlifting and squatting on the same day is a way to limit the gains you’ll enjoy from these two fantastic exercises. Give them the time and attention they deserve, and the rewards will pay you back handsomely from a physical performance and aesthetic point of view.

So, no more deadlifting and squatting on the same day – science says so!


steve hoyles mygym and hoyles fitness

Steve Hoyles is a strength and condoning coach and fitness copywriter. Steve has a diploma from the Institute of Sport and Recreation Management. In a career spanning over two decades, he’s worked with thousands of people from all walks of life. He now owns MyGym, a commercial strength and conditioning gym in Stockport, UK.

white envelope graphic png

Join The MORE STRENGTH Newsletter

Designed to help you build all-round, long-lasting strength. Topics of training, nutrition, mindset, health and recovery.